What Did an NFL Team add to their Training Facility?

by Joseph Giandonato, PhD, MBA, CSCS

The Minnesota Vikings captured headlines this week, not for acquiring Kirk Cousins or releasing Odell Beckham, Jr., but adding an environmental chamber in advance of their mid-season showdown against the San Francisco 49ers in Mexico City.

Introduction

The role of altitude training has been studied extensively since the 1968 Summer Olympic games in Mexico City when numerous Olympic records were shattered owing to the host city’s altitude of 2,300 meters (approximately 7,400 feet) above sea level. The Olympic games and improved performances across a continuum of events gave rise to the popular “live high-train low” methodology widely employed by endurance athletes and coaches to this day. “Live high-train low” methodology among other hypoxic training methods aimed at improving exercise performance at high altitudes as well as monitoring practices will be explored.

Background

At an altitude of 2,300 meters or 7,400 feet above sea level, measuring the elevation of the region in which the 1968 Summer Olympic games were held, VO2max is approximately 88% of sea level values (Howley & Thompson, 2017). Decrements in maximal oxygen consumption are attributable to reduced partial pressure of oxygen leading to increases in heart rate, pulmonary ventilation, and cardiac output at submaximal intensities, including rest, since blood contains less oxygen at higher altitudes. Engaging in exercise at altitude that would be considered submaximal at sea level would be nullified due to each liter of blood having less oxygen at higher altitudes, in turn requiring that more oxygenated blood is delivered to tissues resulting in a higher heart rate. In addition to reduced partial pressure of oxygen at higher elevations, colder ambient temperatures are also noted, as is a reduction in water vapor per unit volume of gas. Lessened water vapor presence may result in significant evaporative heat loss and dehydration, particularly at extreme elevations for which acclimatization is neither safe, nor practical. 

Initial exposure to altitude may result in acute hypoxia, a condition characterized by reduced arterial blood oxygen levels, that inhibits exercise performance, execution of motor skill related tasks, neuromuscular and neurocognitive functioning at higher elevations. Acute hypoxia risks and associated responses are magnified among non-acclimatized individuals. Since the partial pressure of oxygen is diminished at higher elevations, ventilatory rate increases to help the body meet its increased oxygen demand. Additionally, the partial pressure of other gases, specifically carbon dioxide, at higher elevations is lower, resulting in hyperventilation. Lowed carbon dioxide results in higher blood pH, in which the kidneys excrete a greater amount of bicarbonate ions to recalibrate the body’s blood acid balance. Symptoms of high blood pH include nausea, vomiting, and numbness in the appendages. Increased cardiac output is also noted at higher altitudes, largely stemming from an increased heart rate (up to 40 to 50% at rest) without a change in stroke volume (Hoffman, 2014). Reductions in stroke volume are linked to reduced blood plasma volume which are observed shortly after arrival at altitude. Reductions in blood plasma volume are correlative with altitude and the result of diuresis stemming from large evaporative heat losses by ventilation of drier air at higher elevations.

Adaptations to Altitude Exposure and Training

In order to confer physiological responses conducive to improved performance, athletes and coaches have instituted hypoxic training methods involving deliberate and gradual exposure to higher elevations in both training and at rest. These methods are intended to not only evoke improvements in endurance performance, but also aimed at upholding athlete safety. One of the most commonly approaches involves living at higher altitudes, but training at lower altitudes, also known as the “live high-train low” methodology. This approach was modified as living at moderate altitude (2,500 meters above sea level) and training at a low altitude and compared with living and training at a moderate altitude (2,500 meters above sea level) and living and training at sea level. Following six weeks of base training at sea level, 39 competitive runners (27 men and 12 women), all sea level residents with recent 5km event times, were divided among the groups and performed a four-week training program consisting of an acclimatization week, followed by two weeks of increasing volume and intensity, with a taper during the final week which preceded a 5km run test. The groups who lived at moderate altitude and trained at lower altitude and lived and trained at moderate altitude significantly improved their VO2max, however, only members of the living at moderate altitude and training at lower altitude group improved their 5km times (Levine & Stray-Gunderson, 1997). Velocity at maximal steady state was also noted among this group, likely owing to increased red blood cell production, which is hallmark adaptation of altitude exposure. Adaptations to prolonged altitude exposure and training also include increased mitochondrial density and capillary networks, increased oxidative enzymes which collectively elevate aerobic metabolism during exercise.

Erythropoiesis

The design and implementation of hypoxic training methods are predicated upon the optimization of the hormone, erythropoietin. Erythropoietin is a signaling protein that is secreted in the kidneys that stimulates red blood cell production in the bone marrow. This process, known as erythropoiesis, propagates red blood cell production, beginning at initial altitude exposure throughout prolonged exposure periods (Sinex & Chapman, 2015) lasting up to 24 to 48 hours (Hoffman, 2014). Increases in red cell mass continue even when erythropoietin levels return to baseline. Increases in red cell mass, in addition to initial increased erythropoietin levels were noted among cross country skiers living at altitudes of 2,500 meters above sea level and training at sea level for a period of 24 days (Wehrlin, Zuest, Hallén, & Marti, 2006). Continuous exposure to hypoxic environments for 24 days and “live high-train low” approaches consisting of residing at elevations of 1,800 to 2,800 meters and training at 800 to 1,250 meters have been proven efficacious in improving endurance exercise performance among elite and highly trained endurance athletes (Sinex & Chapman, 2015). Increases of hemoglobin, a transport protein found in red blood cells, which delivers oxygen to tissue, were noted among elite swimmers partaking in a 26-day long altitude training program (Zheng, 2021).

Programming Considerations

Variability in responses to altitude exposure and training is inherent to the design and delivery of programming that is effective, efficient, and safe. Hormonal and nutritional status should be monitored (Zheng, 2021) as both carry immense implications on health and performance. Iron levels are of critical importance, since iron is a constituent of red blood cells and hemoglobin. Iron deficiencies are widely observed among endurance athletes, which can be compounded during menstruation or among individuals with sickle cell trait. Athletes should be screened for sickle cell trait prior to altitude exposure or engaging in altitude training. Strenuous exercise coupled with high altitudes may increase risk of splenic infarction, in which the spleen becomes inflamed from the sickling of red blood cells, potentially leading to pleural effusion and severe anemia (Sheikha, 2005). In some cases, removal of the spleen is warranted.

Responses to altitude training among males and females differs. Zheng (2021) demonstrated decreased testosterone levels among male subjects in their third week of altitude training, whereas testosterone levels increased among females. Further, Zheng (2021) reported that elite and highly trained athletes with extensive training histories may not benefit from altitude training as well as their younger and lesser trained counterparts with fewer training years noting unnecessary complications to long term immunological and endocrine functioning.

Though artificial hypoxic training protocols afforded by hypobaric chambers and tents and inhalers, have been shown to improve endurance exercise performance (Sinex & Chapman, 2015), they can interfere with sleep (Hoffman, 2014) while accompanied with onerous costs related to procurement and maintenance.

Deploying hypoxic training methods may cause immunosuppression and elevate blood clotting risk among athletes, therefore warranting careful screening of program participants for preexisting conditions and contraindications such as a recent surgery, deep vein thrombosis, prescribed oral contraceptives or hormone replacement therapy, or have survived cancer.

For endurance athletes training for an event at a high elevation, it is recommended that periodized programming be employed which incorporates deliberate but gradual manipulations in loading parameters such frequency, intensity, duration, and volume of exercise and incremental exposure to altitude environments (if using artificial hypoxic training protocols) and titrating down exercise intensity, especially if temporarily relocating to a higher altitude to facilitate training. Monitoring of immunological and endocrine functioning as well as nutrition status should be ongoing throughout the altitude training program (Mujika, Sharma, & Stellingwerf, 2019; Zheng, 2021) providing critical feedback to modify loading parameters or autoregulation. 

A period of two weeks prior to competition is required for acclimatization, however, if improvements in performance or specifically mimicking sea level performance is desired, a longer acclimatization period ranging from four to six weeks is recommended. Additionally, during the first two weeks of the acclimatization period, training intensity should be reduced to 60-70% of sea level intensity and gradually increased over the next 10 to 14 days. Athletes training at higher elevations can realize improvements in endurance performance within 24 to 26 days, therefore, no longer than one month spent training or living at higher elevations may be necessary to elicit improvements red blood cell production. Specific recommendations to allay illnesses associated with altitude, including acute mountain sickness, high-altitude cerebral edema, and high-altitude pulmonary edema include gradually increasing altitude (300 meters per day) at elevations higher than 3000 meters above sea level.

Conclusion

In summary, is imperative that athletes and coaches recognize the risks of altitude exposure and training, their acute responses and longer-term transmutations, and closely examine and evaluate hypoxic training methods prior to competition. Altitude training can proffer performance benefits, however, the logistics and risks associated with it can be immense and detrimental to health. 

References

Hoffman, J. (2014). Physiological aspects of sport training and performance (2nd ed.). Human Kinetics, Champaign.

Howley, E.T. & Thompson, D.L. (2017). Fitness professional’s handbook (7th ed.). Human Kinetics, Champaign.

Levine, B.D. & Stray-Gunderson, J. (1997). “Living high-training low”: Effect of moderate-altitude acclimatization with low-altitude training on performance. Journal of Applied Physiology, 83 (1), 102-112.

Mujika, I., Sharma, A.P., & Stellingwerf, T. (2019). Contemporary periodization of altitude training for elite endurance athletes: A narrative review. Sports Medicine, 49 (1), 1651-1669.

Sheika, A. (2005). Splenic syndrome in patients at high altitude with unrecognized sickle cell trait splenectomy is often unnecessary. Canadian Journal of Surgery, 48 (5), 377-381.

Wehrlin, J.P., Zuest, P., Hallén, J., Marti, B. (2006). Live high-train low for 24 days increases hemoglobin mass and red cell volume in elite endurance athletes. Journal of Applied Physiology, 100 (1), 1938-1945.